1
← Press roomPress pack: print this page (Ctrl+P / ⌘P) to get the full PDF.

OneDpe study

Redone French energy certificates: 44.8% of energy sieves leave classes F and G with no measure recorded, 84.8% with one

When a measure is recorded, the difference is clear. But two certificates for the same home do not always say the same thing.

According to a OneDpe study of ADEME’s full public certificate database, 44.8% of energy sieves (homes rated F or G) assessed twice leave those classes at the second assessment with no renovation measure (windows, heating, ventilation, insulation, hot water) recorded, against 84.8% when a measure is recorded. Both rates leave aside, on both sides, the homes whose second certificate is worse than the first (18% of the 104,759 homes assessed twice). Re-issued for the same visit, with no works possible, a certificate changes class in 17.2% of cases, one way or the other.

Study published on · Figures frozen on · Source: OneDpe.fr

Key figures

Same scale44.8%
of energy sieves assessed twice leave classes F and G at the second certificate with none of the six tracked measures recorded, against 84.8% when a measure is recorded, leaving aside the cases where the second certificate is worse than the first
6,878 out of 15,359 with no measure recorded; 9,351 out of 11,026 with one. Homes whose second certificate is worse than the first (18% of the 104,759) are left aside on both sides. “No measure recorded” does not mean “no works”.
Same scale17.2%
of certificates re-issued for the same visit change class, with no works possible: 12.8% gain at least one, 4.4% lose at least one
195,669 out of 1,139,724, with identical conversion factor and calculation version. A re-issue is a new document drawn up for the same visit, for example to correct a floor area or an entry.
Same scale1.26
classes gained on average by changing the heating system, when it is the only measure recorded, against 0.69 for windows, the most frequent measure
When a single measure is recorded. Windows concern 40.7% of homes with a measure, heating 34.0%.
Direct count9 in 10
replaced certificates re-issue the same visit, for example to correct a floor area or an entry: not a new assessment
1,862,697 out of 2,040,000 replacements recorded by ADEME since July 2021 (91%), a normal act for an assessor. The study covers the 104,759 homes genuinely assessed twice, on two separate visits.

Same scale: both ratings brought to the same scale and the same electricity conversion factor before being compared · Direct count: a count in the ADEME database, with no reclassification of ratings.

« An energy certificate is not a measurement to the millimetre. When an energy sieve is assessed again with no measure recorded, and the second certificate is not worse, nearly one time in two it leaves classes F and G. When the second certificate records a measure, the gap is clear: more than eight energy sieves in ten leave F and G. But as long as the gap between two certificates for the same home is not documented, we cannot say precisely what the works have changed. »
— Steven Annonziata, co-founder of OneDpe (RIANN SAS) and author of the study

What the study shows

At the second certificate, 44.8% of energy sieves leave F and G with no measure recorded, 84.8% with one

Since July 2021, 104,759 homes assessed twice, on two separate visits, fall within the study’s scope. A recorded measure is a declared improvement to equipment or insulation between the two certificates. Among energy sieves whose second certificate records none of the six measures tracked (windows, heating, ventilation, walls, roof, hot water), 44.8% leave classes F and G. When a measure is recorded, it is 84.8%. To compare like with like, homes whose second certificate is worse than the first are left aside, whether or not a measure is recorded: they make up 18% of the total. The gap therefore works both ways. “No measure recorded” does not mean “no works”: the second certificate simply describes none. For the rental decency rules, the home’s official rating is what counts.

Heating gains the most classes

When a single measure is recorded, changing the heating system gains 1.26 classes on average, hot water 1.07, wall insulation 0.97, ventilation 0.82, the roof 0.74 and windows 0.69. Yet windows are the most frequent measure: 40.7% of homes where a measure is recorded. When the old certificate recommended a package of works and the second records at least one measure, 8% of homes reach the consumption simulated after that package (2,305 homes).

Same visit, two certificates: 17.2% change class

The minimum gap between two entries of the same visit is measured on re-issued certificates, where no works are possible. Out of 1,139,724 re-issues with the same conversion factor and calculation version, 17.2% change class: 12.8% gain at least one, 4.4% lose at least one. And 26.2% of energy sieves leave classes F and G; the study does not say why the certificate was re-issued. The displayed final energy consumption changes in 59.5% of cases: the median gap is nil, but it is wide at the edge of the classes, exactly where energy-sieve status is decided.

Nine replaced certificates in ten re-issue the same visit

ADEME has recorded 2,040,000 certificate replacements since July 2021. 91% re-issue the same visit, a normal act for an assessor; 104,759 homes fall within the study’s scope (two separate visits, same postcode, floor area within 25%, homes assessed individually). The stated reason says little about works, both ways: 54.8% of second certificates citing “works” record a measure, and 84.4% of second certificates that record a measure do not cite “works”.

By region and by département

Recorded measures differ between regions: in Île-de-France, windows appear in 49.6% of homes where a measure is recorded; heating appears in 56.7% in Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur and 52.1% in Occitanie. Results are published for 12 regions and 38 départements, those with at least 300 homes with a measure recorded, without any ranking between them. The regional press kit on this page lists them by département number.

What the study does not say

  • It blames no assessor: the gap between two certificates for the same home is a property of the system, and no statistic by professional is produced.
  • It does not say that redoing a certificate is a way out of energy-sieve status: it measures a gap that works both ways, since 18% of second assessments are worse.
  • A “recorded measure” is a declared change of state between two certificates: it is neither dated, invoiced nor verified. The study covers neither the cost of works nor grants.
  • It covers homes assessed twice, not the whole housing stock.

The copy, the method, the data

The full analysis does not cut well from the bottom. Rather than let it be trimmed badly, the copy is here — free to reuse, including commercially, with the credit “Source: OneDpe.fr”. For anyone who would rather check the count than reuse it, the method note gives the perimeter, the keys, the conventions and the limits in full. And for anyone who would rather do their own local angle, the data are served as a spreadsheet file, area by area.

Infographics

Free to reuse, including commercially, with the credit “Source: OneDpe.fr”. Click a thumbnail to enlarge and download — PNG 3200 px, editable SVG, greyscale proof.

  • 44.8% of energy sieves leave F and G with no measure recorded, 84.8% with one

  • Heating gains almost twice as many classes as windows

  • Same visit, two certificates: 17.2% change class

  • 9 in 10 replaced certificates re-issue the same visit

  • Recommended package: 8% of homes reach the simulated consumption

The other figures in the file

Direct count8%
of homes whose old certificate recommended a package of works, and whose second certificate records at least one measure, reach the consumption simulated after that package2,305 homes; 3.8% when the home starts at F, 22.9% when it starts at C. The recommended package is not a record of the works done.
Direct count54.8%
of second certificates citing “works” as the reason actually record a measure4,979 out of 9,088. Conversely, 84.4% of second certificates that record a measure do not cite “works”: the stated reason says little, both ways.
Direct count59.5%
of certificates re-issued for the same visit show a different consumption from the document they replace678,651 out of 1,139,724, with identical conversion factor and calculation version; the median gap is nil.

The data

Energy sieves assessed again: exits from classes F and G by what the second certificate records

What the second certificate recordsEnergy sieves at the startExits from F and GShare
A measure recorded11,0269,35184.8%
None of the six measures recorded15,3596,87844.8%

Homes assessed twice on two separate visits, leaving aside the cases where the second certificate is worse than the first (18% of the 104,759 homes, left aside with or without a measure). Ratings brought to the same electricity conversion factor (1.9) and the same scale. The breakdown of the group with no measure recorded is in the method note.

The six measures, among the 31,953 homes where a measure is recorded

MeasureHomesShareClasses gained, single measureFinal energy consumption, median change, single measure (kWh/m²/yr)
Windows12,99340.7%0.69−28
Heating (another type of system)10,84934.0%1.26−60
Mechanical ventilation10,82833.9%0.82−26
Hot water (heat-pump or solar water heater)3,46210.8%1.07−33
Walls (insulation)3,0109.4%0.97−46
Roof (insulation)2,0846.5%0.74−37

Measures add up: a single measure in 72.9% of cases.

The minimum gap: certificates re-issued for the same visit

IndicatorValue
Re-issues with the same conversion factor and calculation version1,139,724
Change class195,669 (17.2%)
… of which gain at least one class145,674 (12.8%)
… of which lose at least one class49,995 (4.4%)
Energy sieves leaving F and G26.2%
Different displayed final energy consumption678,651 (59.5%)

No works are possible between two editions of the same visit: this is the minimum gap between two entries of the same assessment. The study does not say why the certificate was re-issued; 4.4% of re-issues lose at least one class.

Methodology

Published in full so anyone can check, replicate or challenge it.

Scope, definition, sources and limits

Scope

104,759 homes assessed twice since July 2021: a certificate and the one that replaced it, on two separate visits (more than 7 days apart), same postcode, floor area within ±25%, homes assessed individually (excluding certificates generated from a whole-building certificate). Minimum gap between two entries: 1,139,724 re-issues of the same visit, with the same conversion factor and calculation version.

What the figure means

A measure is recorded when the declared state of a component changes for the better between the two certificates: insulated walls or roof, better windows, ventilation turned mechanical, heating changed to another system type, heat-pump or solar hot water. Both certificates are brought to the same conversion factor and scale before being compared.

Sources

  • ADEME, certificates for existing homes since July 2021, full extraction of 25 August 2026 (19,502,445 active and replaced certificates), Licence Ouverte 2.0.
  • Replacement link declared by the assessor and checked both ways (2,039,333 out of 2,040,000 consistent); visit date.
  • Ratings brought to the statutory scale and the 1.9 electricity conversion factor, the one for certificates issued in 2026 in mainland France (order of 13 August 2025), checked on 3,950,397 certificates (99.678% agreement with the published class). For certificates issued in mainland France from 1 January 2027, this factor is 1.7 (order of 19 August 2026), a text that postdates the data.
  • Study produced by OneDpe (RIANN SAS), publisher of certificate analysis tools: the commercial interest is declared. Calculation chain and frozen data available on request.

Limits — what this study does NOT say

  • Homes assessed twice, not the stock: the population depends on a declared replacement.
  • A recorded measure is a declared change of state, neither dated, invoiced nor verified; the database holds no record of completed works.
  • The headline comparison leaves aside, on both sides, the cases where the second certificate is worse than the first (18% of homes). The detail of the other readings is in the method note.
  • No cost, no grant, no return on investment, no assessor identity.

About OneDpe

OneDpe.fr is an independent platform of analysis tools for the French energy performance certificate (DPE). It offers free tools — certificate consistency checks, discount estimation, 3CL simulation, simulation of the rating under the 1.7 factor for certificates issued in mainland France from 1 January 2027, renovation works estimation — built on the analysis of several million certificates from the ADEME open data, cross-referenced with French property transaction data (DVF). OneDpe is published by RIANN SAS (Paris).

Going further

Journalist? Detailed figures, interviews and custom breakdowns: presse@onedpe.fr — same-day reply; on publication day, from 06:00 Paris time.

Steven Annonziata, co-founder of OneDpe (RIANN SAS) and author of the study — available to comment, in French or English, the same day.